Clinton unveils mandatory health care insurance plan

brett636

Well-Known Member
To those of you that support hillary care let me leave you with this thought. To get an idea of how much better a government run program does versus a market driven company you only need look at UPS versus the USPS. We move more packages than the post office dispite how they have government subsidized rates. People pay more money to let a private company do the work of a much cheaper government run agency. Now if the government has trouble getting a package from here to there, how do you expect them to get you fixed right when something goes wrong with you? One only needs to look at socialized medicines of other countries. Its a disaster and I don't want to pay for it.
 

brett636

Well-Known Member
I could have quoted a lot of you about what you think about Canadas health care plan .If you are a citizen you get a health card. No cost to you to visit a doctor.No cost if you need surgery unless its cosmetic.
In rural areas it may be hard to find a doctor,but 99% of us live in cities where doctors are quite accessable.If you have a family doctor,you can usually get in the same day or the next,depending on your ailment.Most people just go to "walk in clinics"and yes you have to wait your turn.
My dad had a colostomy when he was around 45. 10 years later he had a double bypass operation.My mom had serious liver problems and basically spent the last year of her life in the hospital.My dad lived to 73 years old thanks to our health care system.I had a hemmoroid operation that made my life at ups a million times more bareable.There is something to be said for government health care,it seems to work .

So why are Canadian citizens flocking to the U.S. for healthcare they can get in their own country for free? Seems to me that healthcard is not worth as much as you think.
 

brownmonster

Man of Great Wisdom
Maybe if you had to wait for health care people wouldn't run to the doctor ror every runny nose and hang nail. Old people go to the doctor because they're bored.
 

truce

Member
brett636, where did you get such weird facts? How many of you have actually been to even Canada, let alone other countries?

In my State of America, I wait an average 3-4 weeks for a doctor's appointment, unless it was scheduled 12 months in advance. Then I know that my appointment is confirmed for next Fall. Then, if I just call around to see any doctor for an unscheduled issue, there is absolutely no possible way to get in with anyone. Most doctors are booked with a long, long line of patients.

We only rely on emergency care. This is why everyone has a false sense that you can get immediate health care in America. ER is outrageously expensive. Lots of countries have ERs, and it's possible that they have better emergency service levels. I've been to one ER in the US. It took 3 hours to get a minor issue taken care of...

Yes, Europeans pay a lot in taxes for medical care, but I had a hernia surgery in Germany. It was a mandatory 2-week stay in the hospital with meals provided (and beer downstairs). In the US it's a darn ambulatory surgery! How ridiculous!

Insurance companies have raised the cost of medical care to an absolute maximum in this country. Why do people keep taking it? Why do we keep paying these crazy insurance rates? They are a lot higher than what the government would charge for tax. But God forbid we pay money to the government. We would rather stuff pockets of private companies that in some cases are willing to backstab people.

Why is everyone so anti-government? The only time people support the government is when we pour money into the Pentagon. Don't you see this funny connection here?

Maybe Hillary's plan is not so good, but give nationalized health care an opportunity. Personal health is a human right. This is why so many of us are so unhealthy. You may have to wait for certain surgeries in certain countries. In the US, we wait because we have no choice. Millions of us are without insurance, after all. Some of you UPS grunts with lots of years may not understand this. Our company is one of very few to provide such great benefits. Life is tough on the outside right now.

Canada and European countries try to practice preventative care. We wait until we can't wait no more to fix ourselves.

I am an immigrant, and I accepted my American Government as my own. It does a lot of great things for everyone. If only it had support from it's own people, it could set a truly inspiring and positive tone for the entire world.
 

rushfan

Well-Known Member
Don't trust the government to fix anything. Why don't they fix their spending issues and other internal issues before trying to force something on me. If the government ran like UPS there would be a budget surplus, not a deficit. Please, socialized medicine, another waste of money. Not the way to go in my book.
 

kingOFchester

Well-Known Member
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO AND NO
Let me pay for my own health care. I am at UPS for 2 reasons.
1) health care
2) To maybe drive someday

If you take 2 out of the equation, I would still work here for the insurance. I work 7 days a week(70hrs). Been doing so for 18 years of my life. There have been years where I made very little money, but never took a hand out. Not knocking anyone who does, but until I have exhausted ALL of my options, I do not want a hand out that will raise taxes or that the hard working tax payer has to pay. Smaller government and keep them out of my life as much as possible.
 
Last edited:

bsmoking

Member
they have the same kind of health care in europe and they all come over here for the services they dont get there,, bad idea, if it goes in to effect you may have a ANIMAL DOCTOR WORKING ON YOUR HEART, any body could be a doctor undr that plan
 

sendagain

Well-Known Member
They throw out a number like 110 billion dollars and think "how great will this be", and that is just a projection to begin the program; this is a cost that would climb every year for as long as we continue. They complain about the cost of the war in Iraq, then they want to spend at least that much money or more on another program that will never end. Why doesn't she cough up the 12 million dollars raised for her senatorial race that wasn't spent, and donate that to some health clinics.
 

beatupbrown

Well-Known Member
Folks we have a broken health care system in the USA.
While we rank number 1 worldwide in health-related spending, we rank 37th in overall health performance.
The assumptions upon which the current system are built are outdated, obsolete, and illogical. The system requires a wholesale reevaluation and rebuilding from the bottom up, including our rights, our responsibilities - and our reasonable expectations. If virtually every other developed nation (and several underdeveloped) can take care of their sick, we certainly ought to be given the chance.
This profit-driven insurance-based medical reimbursement system is fatally flawed on several levels – and always has been. The basic business model of any insurance company is to do everything possible to collect premiums and then do everything possible to deny coverage. Therefore, people who need medical attention are frequently denied expensive (but often the most effective) treatment or, alternatively, people with pre-existing conditions can’t get insurance coverage in the first place - when they are the ones who need it most. As a result, insurance companies often dictate the most critical medical decisions more than the physicians. It’s just so wrong.:ohmy:
 

kingOFchester

Well-Known Member
Folks we have a broken health care system in the USA.
While we rank number 1 worldwide in health-related spending, we rank 37th in overall health performance.
The assumptions upon which the current system are built are outdated, obsolete, and illogical. The system requires a wholesale reevaluation and rebuilding from the bottom up, including our rights, our responsibilities - and our reasonable expectations. If virtually every other developed nation (and several underdeveloped) can take care of their sick, we certainly ought to be given the chance.
This profit-driven insurance-based medical reimbursement system is fatally flawed on several levels – and always has been. The basic business model of any insurance company is to do everything possible to collect premiums and then do everything possible to deny coverage. Therefore, people who need medical attention are frequently denied expensive (but often the most effective) treatment or, alternatively, people with pre-existing conditions can’t get insurance coverage in the first place - when they are the ones who need it most. As a result, insurance companies often dictate the most critical medical decisions more than the physicians. It’s just so wrong.:ohmy:
Sure, I will give you that. BUT, there is other ways to solve the problem. Ways, that I feel, are far better then Clintons plan. JMHO
 

brett636

Well-Known Member
Folks we have a broken health care system in the USA.
While we rank number 1 worldwide in health-related spending, we rank 37th in overall health performance.
The assumptions upon which the current system are built are outdated, obsolete, and illogical. The system requires a wholesale reevaluation and rebuilding from the bottom up, including our rights, our responsibilities - and our reasonable expectations. If virtually every other developed nation (and several underdeveloped) can take care of their sick, we certainly ought to be given the chance.
This profit-driven insurance-based medical reimbursement system is fatally flawed on several levels – and always has been. The basic business model of any insurance company is to do everything possible to collect premiums and then do everything possible to deny coverage. Therefore, people who need medical attention are frequently denied expensive (but often the most effective) treatment or, alternatively, people with pre-existing conditions can’t get insurance coverage in the first place - when they are the ones who need it most. As a result, insurance companies often dictate the most critical medical decisions more than the physicians. It’s just so wrong.:ohmy:

While our healthcare system is not perfect, it does offer the best healthcare in the world. You say we rank 37th in overall health performance, and I assume you mean the individual health of the average americans. Are you sure that isn't due to poor health choices Americans make? When it comes down to who decides what kind of medical care I get, the doctors decide what I need, the insurance companies keep them from getting overly greedy. The free market allows for a much more efficient system. In the end I would much rather have a private insurance company than a government bureaucracy
 

aspenleaf

Well-Known Member
My mother lives in Holland. They have free health care. She had to wait THREE MONTHS to see a doctor when she hurt her knee and she tells me on a weekly basis of the horror stories of this thing called free health care that her and her friends and family have to face. She had to travel to Belgium (not actually that far from her home) to get some treatment. That was about a year ago. TO THIS DAY she has not had a good care and still suffers. Doctors do not make enough money so the best ones go - guess where?- you got it -here. As bad as it is here the grass is not always greener.....

YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR


THANK - YOU! Free does not mean it would be the quality we are used to here in this country. I agree that our system is a mess but trying mirror what other countries have won't work.
 

blue efficacy

Well-Known Member
sounds great on paper but it will never work in this country. There's gonna be alot of people freeload the fruits of our labor........
Yeah, like all the people who have no choice but to work for Walmart and the like who work hard but still receive inadequate health care. Those ****ing freeloaders!
 

blue efficacy

Well-Known Member
While our healthcare system is not perfect, it does offer the best healthcare in the world. You say we rank 37th in overall health performance, and I assume you mean the individual health of the average americans. Are you sure that isn't due to poor health choices Americans make? When it comes down to who decides what kind of medical care I get, the doctors decide what I need, the insurance companies keep them from getting overly greedy. The free market allows for a much more efficient system. In the end I would much rather have a private insurance company than a government bureaucracy
Of course you think that, you're a union employee with a secured access to available health care. Millions aren't so lucky!
 

brett636

Well-Known Member
brett636, where did you get such weird facts? How many of you have actually been to even Canada, let alone other countries?

Do a little research, its out there. The comment about Spain came directly from a Cancer specialist here in the states.

In my State of America, I wait an average 3-4 weeks for a doctor's appointment, unless it was scheduled 12 months in advance. Then I know that my appointment is confirmed for next Fall. Then, if I just call around to see any doctor for an unscheduled issue, there is absolutely no possible way to get in with anyone. Most doctors are booked with a long, long line of patients.

While this maybe true in countries with socialized medicine, I have a hard time buying that this is occuring here. If I need to see a doctor I can leave my house now and be seen by my doctor in about an hour. No emergency room visit required, and I bet no Canadian can say the same.

We only rely on emergency care. This is why everyone has a false sense that you can get immediate health care in America. ER is outrageously expensive. Lots of countries have ERs, and it's possible that they have better emergency service levels. I've been to one ER in the US. It took 3 hours to get a minor issue taken care of...

The problems with socialized medicine are apparent in those that already recieve free heathcare courtesy of our government. Its those same people that are running to the emergency room for a runny nose that causes long delays for those that actually need treatment. If I need to go to an emergency room I can go downtown and wait 3-5 hours to be seen, or I can go to an emergency room in the hospital in the next county where they have less people on government health progams and get treated almost immediatly. As far as your issue you described above if it was minor why were you at the emergency room?

Yes, Europeans pay a lot in taxes for medical care, but I had a hernia surgery in Germany. It was a mandatory 2-week stay in the hospital with meals provided (and beer downstairs). In the US it's a darn ambulatory surgery! How ridiculous!

I don't know of any surgeries that are regularly carried out in an ambulance, but I do know hernia surgeries are usually outpatient deals without too many complications. The 2-week stay you mentioned is a gross waste for such a minor surgery, and a very good showing of why we don't want government run healthcare here. That 2-week stay is using up hospital resources that could be going towards people who really need it.

Insurance companies have raised the cost of medical care to an absolute maximum in this country. Why do people keep taking it? Why do we keep paying these crazy insurance rates? They are a lot higher than what the government would charge for tax. But God forbid we pay money to the government. We would rather stuff pockets of private companies that in some cases are willing to backstab people.

I would much rather my healthcare monies go towards private insurance companies than a government that will waste it on people who feel its their right to stay 2 weeks in a hospital for minor surgeries.

Why is everyone so anti-government? The only time people support the government is when we pour money into the Pentagon. Don't you see this funny connection here?

National defense should be the government's only real concern, and why it was created. National defense is the only thing the government gets right.

Maybe Hillary's plan is not so good, but give nationalized health care an opportunity. Personal health is a human right. This is why so many of us are so unhealthy. You may have to wait for certain surgeries in certain countries. In the US, we wait because we have no choice. Millions of us are without insurance, after all. Some of you UPS grunts with lots of years may not understand this. Our company is one of very few to provide such great benefits. Life is tough on the outside right now.

Atleast you got something right, and that is that hillarycare is not such a good plan. There are a lot of people without insurance, but what most don't understand is there are government progams that will cover them. Need prescriptions when you don't have insurance? The drug companies have programs for people who need medication but can't afford it. Also you cannot be refused medical treatment in this country. If you show up at an emergency room you will get treated.

Canada and European countries try to practice preventative care. We wait until we can't wait no more to fix ourselves.

I am an immigrant, and I accepted my American Government as my own. It does a lot of great things for everyone. If only it had support from it's own people, it could set a truly inspiring and positive tone for the entire world.

Do you even know why America is such a great country? I'll give you a hint, it has nothing to do with our government. America is all about the individual. Individual rights foster individual acheivements, and everyone benefits from this. The government only takes a problem and makes it worse, and that is why we don't want them invovled in our healthcare decisions.
 

brett636

Well-Known Member
I should add that I do know people on government run health programs here in the U.S., and those are the people who have to wait 2-4 weeks to see a doctor. I see what they go through and I have to ask myself, "why would I want this for me?" If the government can't get it right for the small percentage of our population that it does cover, how in the world can anyone think it will work better when they cover the entire population? The answer is it won't.
 

cheryl

I started this.
Staff member
I’ve recently been trying to educate myself about the health care reform issues.

Since Tony left UPS we've had to buy our own health insurance. Several insurance companies actually said that I was uninsurable because of my history, which really isn't that bad. We wound up having to buy insurance as a small business covering me as an employee through a corporation that we had previously set up for an investment property. After my cobra coverage through UPS expired that was the only way I could get health insurance coverage.

I think that the system is broken, but I’m not sure who has the approach that might fix it. Clinton’s proposal is way too broad for me…

Libertarian (94) https://web.archive.org/web/20080605185735/http://www.lp.org/lpn/9403-phc-summary.html

Mayo Clinic https://web.archive.org/web/2009110....org/feature-articles/health-care-reform.html

Heritage Foundation http://www.heritage.org/Research/HealthCare/hl1030.cfm

Additional Info:

CATO Policy Anaylsis http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa184.html

Health Care Spending in the United States and OECD Countries https://web.archive.org/web/20110726220326/http://www.kff.org/insurance/snapshot/chcm010307oth.cfm
 

beatupbrown

Well-Known Member
People who say that the private sector do a better job then the government when it comes to health care should take note.
For all their differences, other countries publicly regulate the provision of health care more closely than the United States. Defenders of the U.S. system often decry these alternatives as forms of "rationing" and "bureaucracy." The United States, however, already has plenty of both, courtesy of the private, profit driven system. Every HMO or managed-care arrangement in the United States rations care - permitting a patient to see a specialist only if referred by a primary-care physician, refusing to cover certain treatments altogether - while the system as a whole rations care according to ability to pay. And even the Wall Street Journal admits that the U.S. system "has accumulated a massive bureaucracy that simply doesn't exist in other countries." Perhaps one fourth of so-called "health care" workers "do nothing but paperwork."
It should not come as any surprise that, for our unmatched levels of spending, the United States gets less than it pays for. What the U.S. system has - inefficiency, red tape, and big profits - is expensive. What it lacks - universal coverage- is priceless.
I am going to take a look at Cheryl's links ,being informed is the key when makeing a choice on this matter folks.:thumbup1:
 
Top