What does being old or being gay have to do with someone relating a personal experience as they saw it? Are we suggesting that being old and gay or just being old or just being gay means one is now incapable of relating a or any truth?
With so many gay people still either in the closet or leading "normal" lives on the surface while maintaining secrets lives below the surface, how do you know for certain those in whom you hold faith are not gay themselves? What if they are older and secretly are themselves gay, what then?
If we find one old, gay person who thus believes that Obama's birth certificate is fake, do we use the earlier alleged premise and thus all people who now believe that Obama's birth certificate is fake is thus in error and in belief of a lie?