Brady vs. Manning?

Discussion in 'Life After Brown' started by browniehound, Jan 19, 2007.

  1. browniehound

    browniehound Well-Known Member

    Who would you rather have if you were starting a team today? And if Manning was on the Patriots would they have won 3 Superbowls? If Brady had Marivin Harrison,Reggie Wayne, Bradon Stokely and Dallas Clark to throw to would he put up the numbers Manning has? I would say no and yes! Brady continues to do it with pedestrian recievers while Manning can't win with a hall of famer and another reciever who would be a number 1 on most teams?

    Is there any suprise Reche Caldwell had a career year this year? In 48 games with the Chargers he had 73 receptions and in 18 with the Patriots he had 78. That's the greatness of Brady my friends.

    I apolize, Cheryl, in advance if this is off-topic.
  2. disneyworld

    disneyworld Active Member

    Why bother debating. The Pats do their talking on the field.
  3. tieguy

    tieguy Banned

    Peyton terrific at reading, great at stepping up to avoid the rush. Great recievers do help him. Swann and stallworth made bradshaw a great QB.

    All of this is however irrelevant. Brady is the best QB and has some nice rings to prove it.
  4. HMMMMM.............lets think.............a winner vs. a looser..........lets rack our brain on this one for about a micro-second.
  5. BCFan

    BCFan Active Member

    Manning is the best no bout adoubt it BC
  6. Overpaid Union Thug

    Overpaid Union Thug Well-Known Member

    Manning is one of the best QBs of all time but only technically. Meaning he can "thread the needle" as good as anyone but we all know his history in big games and it hasn't been pretty. As a University of Tennessee fan I can sympathize with Colts fans. For some reason he just hasn't been able to get it done when it really counts. He just needs to win one big one (not necessarily the Superbowl) in order to get over that hurdle. That hurdle is tomorrow. If he can get the Colts by the Patriots then I think things will get better for him. Regardless of wether they actually win the Superbowl or not.
  7. I would never bet against Brady...too much of a winner.

    Go UPS!

    BLACKBOX Life is a Highway...

    patriots have too much experience...colts,bears and saints just in the way for another super bowl victory! Can I get a "Hell Yeah!"......
  9. over9five

    over9five Moderator Staff Member

    Hell Yeah!
  10. browniehound

    browniehound Well-Known Member

    "Hell Yeah" brother!
  11. upsdawg

    upsdawg UPSDAWG

    I would go with Manning---I was looking for a rematch of the Manning Bros--but NY choked.

    So the real question is ------is it the QB or the receivers that he has that make him successful?? I loved Montana------but if Rice wasn't playing for the 49ers when Montana played---would Montana have been so successful?

    I feel sorry for the Dan Marino's--great QB, but had to retire with no ring!

    Go Colts!!
  12. moreluck

    moreluck golden ticket member

    Marino had no ring, but how many players can say they were in a Jim Carey movie??:lol:
  13. browniehound

    browniehound Well-Known Member

    Or star in a Nutrisystem commercial:laugh:
  14. disneyworld

    disneyworld Active Member

    Eli is terrible-that may never happen.
  15. Pip

    Pip New Member

    I'll probably stick my foot in my mouth here, but Manning and company will be sending Brady home for the season. The key difference will be the colts defense has decided to come together at the right time.

    Anybody but the Patriots!!!!! :laugh: :lol: :w00t: :thumbup1:
  16. beentheredonethat

    beentheredonethat Well-Known Member

    There was a similar debate for who was the best NBA center, Bill Russell or Wilt Chamberlain. The answer for that question is the same as the answer for this question. Count the rings.
  17. over9five

    over9five Moderator Staff Member I'm watching the game....

    Christ, those UPS commercials suck!

    BLACKBOX Life is a Highway...

    Yeah, Whiteboard commercials are a whitewash.......

    Pats lose but you gotta hand it to the Colts for that incredible comeback...
  19. Pip

    Pip New Member


    NEENER NEENER NEENER!!!!!:laugh: :lol: :laugh:
  20. I know can't I just enjoy my football game? UPS has to be there too? lol oh well gotta be at work in a few hours. :thumbup1: