climate catastrophe

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Since you can't grasp very simple, straight-forward concepts, I don't think I'm the problem here.
i actually i agree with what he said " It just seems you want to talk around that and say well unless those individual people are free of any problems, then they shouldn't focus on improving the problems in the world they see, that's an absurd ideology. "

thats why im trying to get u to explain it.
 

refineryworker05

Well-Known Member
yea its true the republicans are a minority party and can only get into power by voter suppression and stuff like that.

i was talking about how democrats went crazy about russia last few years instead of looking in the mirror about big money theyve been taking since at least bill clinton and how that gave us trump.

yea i dont hear of critiques of other conservative parties the way i do about republicans and global warming. they are in a league of their own i think on the world stage.
what does this stuff "democrats went crazy with Russia" mean to you? Who are you talking about?
Yes the republican party in America is an outlier in many ways.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Good, now clean the rest of the house. Grow your competence, means get better at actually doing things. Then you'll gain the understanding of what it take to actually accomplish something. Then you'll gain perspective on how to make other things better. Consuming Marxist propaganda to convince yourself that your shortcomings are everyone else's fault is a decadent, immature indulgance.
i never said im perfect. i could study harder and have better time management and be more ballsy. thats it. im probably 30% to blame. 70% not guilty. i have so much time and need to choose what to improve. i can go to school or i can do my middle class job and be stuck here. i improve either way. its u that seems to have a problem with one vs the other. or even worse that because i dont want to pay the $1500 a month or whatever to live on my own that i cant donate...

u talk about immaturity but your anti socialism reeks of immaturity to me. this is not how intellectually mature philosophers or economists talk. even ayn rand probably had some good ideas, the question is how many? marx did not have a monopoly on truth, but hes hugely influential for the right reasons.

 
Last edited:

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Playing dumb is his go to response when people disagree with him or say something that goes against his left wing narrative. The guy is a complete joke.
can u understand what hes saying? try and explain it.

i agree with refinery workers summary of his ideology " It just seems you want to talk around that and say well unless those individual people are free of any problems, then they shouldn't focus on improving the problems in the world they see, that's an absurd ideology. "
 

zubenelgenubi

I'm a star
i actually i agree with what he said " It just seems you want to talk around that and say well unless those individual people are free of any problems, then they shouldn't focus on improving the problems in the world they see, that's an absurd ideology. "

thats why im trying to get u to explain it.

I will try to explain further. The cleaning your room thing is both an analogy and an example, but you're taking it a little too literally, and then extrapolating from it what is not intended. You keep saying that I think you have to be perfect to do anything, or get to some point of personal development before you are allowed to take action. That's not what any of this means.

A car is a complex machine of interconnected systems. You don't take your car to a lemonade stand and demand the poor kid fix it for you. He has neither the tools nor understanding. You take it to an experienced mechanic.

Society is that much more complex. You don't ask a kid living in the basement how to fix society. The kid, and everyone in the society, makes society better by becoming better themselves. If, as you improve yourself, you find a better way to do something that makes people's lives better, and you put in the time and effort to bring that something to other people, you should get some sort of reward for your efforts, right? By and large, that's capitalism.

But, in the process of actually doing something and getting good at it, and not simply consuming information that makes you feel more qualified than the people actually doing things, you will gain understanding and perspective on the problems we face, and be better equipped to handle them. Multiply that by thousands or millions, how can a society not improve?
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
I will try to explain further. The cleaning your room thing is both an analogy and an example, but you're taking it a little too literally, and then extrapolating from it what is not intended. You keep saying that I think you have to be perfect to do anything, or get to some point of personal development before you are allowed to take action. That's not what any of this means.

A car is a complex machine of interconnected systems. You don't take your car to a lemonade stand and demand the poor kid fix it for you. He has neither the tools nor understanding. You take it to an experienced mechanic.

Society is that much more complex. You don't ask a kid living in the basement how to fix society. The kid, and everyone in the society, makes society better by becoming better themselves. If, as you improve yourself, you find a better way to do something that makes people's lives better, and you put in the time and effort to bring that something to other people, you should get some sort of reward for your efforts, right? By and large, that's capitalism.

But, in the process of actually doing something and getting good at it, and not simply consuming information that makes you feel more qualified than the people actually doing things, you will gain understanding and perspective on the problems we face, and be better equipped to handle them. Multiply that by thousands or millions, how can a society not improve?
yea but the stuff that makes people's lives better isnt always profitable and therefore rewarded by capitalism. capitalism quite often makes peoples lives worse; wall st and big oil are 2 examples. right now we are in a capitalist bubble that will pop and people's lives will get much worse, but already this generation of americans has a lower standard than the previous.

my take on adults living in basements is their opinions shouldnt be discounted although they may not be experts. im obviously not an expert. i could be president only with a team of advisors, not by myself. and i would do a better job than the guys "who know something" because they are corrupt anyways so what they know doesnt matter.

thanks for actually answering, alot of guys like bad idea guy will say something bail and not answer.

what makes you think what you do is all that different from what i do? you only live on your own because you work more than 40 hours a week. i dont have time for that. also i dont really get what you mean by doing something will gain understanding on the problems we face? starting up a business is only going to enlighten you so much about hte problems.

like im looking at tuition right now and its $30,000. does that count as doing something and gaining knowledge? or did i already know this crap before i looked at my course from reading articles. years ago i went to the bank to get info on a mortgage. does that count as doing something or did i already know more from just reading stuff on the housing bubble?
 

zubenelgenubi

I'm a star
yea but the stuff that makes people's lives better isnt always profitable and therefore rewarded by capitalism. capitalism quite often makes peoples lives worse; wall st and big oil are 2 examples. right now we are in a capitalist bubble that will pop and people's lives will get much worse, but already this generation of americans has a lower standard than the previous.

my take on adults living in basements is their opinions shouldnt be discounted although they may not be experts. im obviously not an expert. i could be president only with a team of advisors, not by myself. and i would do a better job than the guys "who know something" because they are corrupt anyways so what they know doesnt matter.

thanks for actually answering, alot of guys like bad idea guy will say something bail and not answer.

what makes you think what you do is all that different from what i do? you only live on your own because you work more than 40 hours a week. i dont have time for that. also i dont really get what you mean by doing something will gain understanding on the problems we face? starting up a business is only going to enlighten you so much about hte problems.

like im looking at tuition right now and its $30,000. does that count as doing something and gaining knowledge? or did i already know this crap before i looked at my course from reading articles. years ago i went to the bank to get info on a mortgage. does that count as doing something or did i already know more from just reading stuff on the housing bubble?

You have to understand that the world is a complex place, certainly far more complex than any one person can ever comprehend. There are billions of different perspectives on the complex world, so to truly relate understanding from even one person to another is a huge commitment.

I don't pretend to believe I can ever fully understand your perspective, nor get you to understand mine. For most it's a chore just to share their perspective, much less explain it. I don't mind giving it a shot when I have a little extra time, and I feel you are sincere and certainly less prone to sarcasm in these exchanges than I am. I feel like I do understand your perspective a little better, though it doesn't mean I will ever see things the same way.

You have your knowledge and experience, I have mine, and there is just not enough time to share it all. This human inability to understand each other to a meaningful degree is a big reason why collectivism fails. I've been married over 20 years, I am still getting to know my wife, the fact that we keep at it despite the difficulties makes life beautiful.

One of the biggest challenges in conversing with you is that you throw out a lot of information. If I try to cut off one head of the hydra of topics you bring to the conversation, two more take its place. If we can keep it focused to one or two topics at a time, then the conversations can have that much more meaning.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
You have to understand that the world is a complex place, certainly far more complex than any one person can ever comprehend. There are billions of different perspectives on the complex world, so to truly relate understanding from even one person to another is a huge commitment.

I don't pretend to believe I can ever fully understand your perspective, nor get you to understand mine. For most it's a chore just to share their perspective, much less explain it. I don't mind giving it a shot when I have a little extra time, and I feel you are sincere and certainly less prone to sarcasm in these exchanges than I am. I feel like I do understand your perspective a little better, though it doesn't mean I will ever see things the same way.

You have your knowledge and experience, I have mine, and there is just not enough time to share it all. This human inability to understand each other to a meaningful degree is a big reason why collectivism fails. I've been married over 20 years, I am still getting to know my wife, the fact that we keep at it despite the difficulties makes life beautiful.

One of the biggest challenges in conversing with you is that you throw out a lot of information. If I try to cut off one head of the hydra of topics you bring to the conversation, two more take its place. If we can keep it focused to one or two topics at a time, then the conversations can have that much more meaning.
congrats on being married for a long time. i hope shes hot on the outside and personality too.

i dont look at it as cutting off one head of topics. were just talking and i thought u had an interesting perspective on improving society. the topics are related. i agree people have a hard time understanding each other and thats probably because we cant get past appearances of our "enemies" and dont have any perspective like listening to them.

i think u guys like to use your achievement of moving out the same way i like to talk about donating or whatever actions ive done to make the world better.

i dont know enough about collectivism to know why it succeeds or fails. my guys are in favor of worker controlled jobs and weary of giving the govt too much power although they are not free market fundamentalists.

ralph nader would probably just say join and form a local congress member watch group. i know chomsky says get organized. chris hedges says rebel. they dont talk about having life wisdom before you join, its kinda understood you've done some research before you've joined and youre going to learn as you go and someone will teach you. most people who protest are the youth so how much wisdom can you expect htem to have. 50% of them are now living at home with the parents, i would argue through little fault of their own. the youth spend too much time in virtual reality; on their phones.

im going to repost this because i was looking for an answer on it and when you have time hopefully u can answer. i dont lie.:

what makes you think what you do is all that different from what i do? you only live on your own because you work more than 40 hours a week. i dont have time for that. also i dont really get what you mean by doing something will gain understanding on the problems we face? starting up a business is only going to enlighten you so much about hte problems.

like im looking at tuition right now and its $30,000. does that count as doing something and gaining knowledge? or did i already know this crap before i looked at my course from reading articles. years ago i went to the bank to get info on a mortgage. does that count as doing something or did i already know more from just reading stuff on the housing bubble
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Union of Concerned Scientists liked

UCS Climate Campaign
@ClimateUCS

·
14h

What's the connection between #climatechange and #wildfires? Check out our new infographic visualizing the connection between #wildfires and #climatechange. Link below.

Personal computer


Books


Right pointing backhand index

https://ucsusa.org/resources/infographic-wildfires-and-climate-change

Image
Image
Image
 
Last edited:

zubenelgenubi

I'm a star
congrats on being married for a long time. i hope shes hot on the outside and personality too.

i dont look at it as cutting off one head of topics. were just talking and i thought u had an interesting perspective on improving society. the topics are related. i agree people have a hard time understanding each other and thats probably because we cant get past appearances of our "enemies" and dont have any perspective like listening to them.

i think u guys like to use your achievement of moving out the same way i like to talk about donating or whatever actions ive done to make the world better.

i dont know enough about collectivism to know why it succeeds or fails. my guys are in favor of worker controlled jobs and weary of giving the govt too much power although they are not free market fundamentalists.

ralph nader would probably just say join and form a local congress member watch group. i know chomsky says get organized. chris hedges says rebel.

they dont talk about having life wisdom before you join, its kinda understood you've done some research before you've joined and youre going to learn as you go and someone will teach you.

That's because they know they can't get followers from amongst people who have a certain level of understanding. They target their message to the types of people they do for a reason.

most people who protest are the youth so how much wisdom can you expect htem to have.

There are plenty of young people who have the wisdom to know that protesting is not effective if you don't know what you are doing. It seems clear to me that most of the protesters across the US are being manipulated by wealthy people, generally the types they are ostensibly protesting against, to further their own agendas. With a little thoughtfulness, perspective, and understanding, these protesters would not be so easily manipulated.


im going to repost this because i was looking for an answer on it and when you have time hopefully u can answer. i dont lie.:

what makes you think what you do is all that different from what i do?

People on this forum give you a hard time partly because they find your views to be naïve, and partly because you embody the cliché of the guy living in his parent's basement. I don't pretend to know all your circumstances, so I bring it up for the metaphorical value, not so much to be derisive.

As for what is so different between what we do, I would say the level of challenge and level of consequence for failure, i.e. risk. It's not very challenging to donate money. Studying and learning is a step up, but has very little risk.

you only live on your own because you work more than 40 hours a week.

I don't live on my own, I am the sole provider for my family. And It's not just because I work 40 or more hours a week. It's because I have worked upwards of 100 hours a week, working multiple jobs when necessary, to put a roof over the heads and food in the mouths of my wife and kids. I worked a full time job while going to college and serving in the National Guard. I have paid all of my student loans off, am close to paying off my mortgage nearly ten years early, and have no other debt.

i dont have time for that.

If that's true, I might suggest it's because you are overly self-indulgant in your anti-capitalism crusade.

also i dont really get what you mean by doing something will gain understanding on the problems we face? starting up a business is only going to enlighten you so much about hte problems.

By taking on a burden, say the burden of taking care of yourself and being your own man, you gain an understanding of just how difficult it is and how much effort it takes even just to do such a simple thing. It's not just starting a business, it's any endeavor that has consequences for failure. But I can assure you, building a successful business takes signifincant effort and a high degree of competence.

like im looking at tuition right now and its $30,000. does that count as doing something and gaining knowledge? or did i already know this crap before i looked at my course from reading articles. years ago i went to the bank to get info on a mortgage. does that count as doing something or did i already know more from just reading stuff on the housing bubble

Having gotten my degree, I can tell you that I did learn a lot, and it was a lot of time and effort. But it is expensive. I only recommend it for someone determined to pursue a career that requires a specific degree. That way you can take a focused approach to your educational path and not waste time and money, and ideally have a career waiting for you that will give you a return on your investment.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
That's because they know they can't get followers from amongst people who have a certain level of understanding. They target their message to the types of people they do for a reason.



There are plenty of young people who have the wisdom to know that protesting is not effective if you don't know what you are doing. It seems clear to me that most of the protesters across the US are being manipulated by wealthy people, generally the types they are ostensibly protesting against, to further their own agendas. With a little thoughtfulness, perspective, and understanding, these protesters would not be so easily manipulated.




People on this forum give you a hard time partly because they find your views to be naïve, and partly because you embody the cliché of the guy living in his parent's basement. I don't pretend to know all your circumstances, so I bring it up for the metaphorical value, not so much to be derisive.

As for what is so different between what we do, I would say the level of challenge and level of consequence for failure, i.e. risk. It's not very challenging to donate money. Studying and learning is a step up, but has very little risk.



I don't live on my own, I am the sole provider for my family. And It's not just because I work 40 or more hours a week. It's because I have worked upwards of 100 hours a week, working multiple jobs when necessary, to put a roof over the heads and food in the mouths of my wife and kids. I worked a full time job while going to college and serving in the National Guard. I have paid all of my student loans off, am close to paying off my mortgage nearly ten years early, and have no other debt.



If that's true, I might suggest it's because you are overly self-indulgant in your anti-capitalism crusade.



By taking on a burden, say the burden of taking care of yourself and being your own man, you gain an understanding of just how difficult it is and how much effort it takes even just to do such a simple thing. It's not just starting a business, it's any endeavor that has consequences for failure. But I can assure you, building a successful business takes signifincant effort and a high degree of competence.



Having gotten my degree, I can tell you that I did learn a lot, and it was a lot of time and effort. But it is expensive. I only recommend it for someone determined to pursue a career that requires a specific degree. That way you can take a focused approach to your educational path and not waste time and money, and ideally have a career waiting for you that will give you a return on your investment.

i havent heard anything about BLM protestor manipulation aside from the undercover cops who try and instigate riots. i have heard about paid protestors before. it seems fairly organic, its obvious america has police problems and race problems, BLM started 6 years ago now and we all know how the ruling elites responded particularily trump. but i dont think its just about race and the police, the country has obviously gone to :censored2:s even more since corona started so i think that plays into it.

revolutions are a numbers game u need 1% of the population in the streets. i forget what else. ive gone to a monsanto protest and i hardly knew anything about them because i forgot. i think they use their market power to :censored2: over farmers. and they have unsafe products. i remember where to look. hopefully these protestors know too.

i agree with u im on the forum too much.

i dont believe in working more than 40 hours a week, and i dont even believe in working 40 i think the labour movement settled for too little. they should cut hours now, and lower costs, and then they could hire more people and bring unemployment down. props to u, that sounds rough. having grown up in a city with an overinflated housing market my plan is to try and move somewhere cool with cheap housing. ive always been nervous about post secondary and tuition too, im lucky i didnt sign up for anything dumb and i want to do cardiology tech and then leave the country.

donating is tough i would argue because we live in a society of greed and cynicism. one of the places i donated to had someone matching donations which is pretty rare for them so i went all in and my donations was one of the biggest. if i moved out, then i couldnt have done that and it wouldve gone to rent, or my donation wouldve been smaller.

people dismiss me for a variety of reasons on the forum. doesnt really matter i like talking about it whether we agree or not. one of which is because it was taboo to talk about socialism until last 10 years. another is probably like the big short movie where theres probably something wrong with us where we dont know how to discuss minority opinions like the housing market is a bubble, or civilization is headed for collapse. probably what u said too about me living at home but thats illegitimate as far as im concerned the housing market is :censored2:ed, labour power is pretty weak, and the company i worked for had major control over the market and had record profits i think and likely ripped us off. some of it is people agree or disagree with someone based on the messenger and not the message. im not a master at wording things: like i dont phrase things a certain way to make people more likely to agree with me (the death tax is one example).

maybe im wrong but i look at our system as meaningless. i like the idea of killing 2 birds with one stone, so that means taking whatever opportunity i have to act and spread consciousness.

so i got a question for you: you have these political and economic beliefs so what do you do related to them besides voting?
 
Top