oldngray
nowhere special
If you go to a HS graduation there is always the group whose attitude is "Let's party dude!" because they aren't planning to go to college and know they are finished with school.
Mike Rowe
- Thread starter Brownslave688
- Start date
If you go to a HS graduation there is always the group whose attitude is "Let's party dude!" because they aren't planning to go to college and know they are finished with school.
DriveInDriveOut
Inordinately Right
I'm a truck driver and I benefited greatly from English classes, I still read a lot and the things I've learned through literature and history helped me better understand the world and be a better citizen in general.
It's about striving for a better society as a whole. People complain that parents are a big part of their child's education then suggest knowledge is useless just learn a trade.
I get what you're saying, but a lot of people demonize trade skills as outdated and as being for stupid people. But a lot of people also demonize higher education as being some liberal sham to make everyone a communist. Its all nonsense.
Brownslave688
You want a toe? I can get you a toe.
And others are named @RonBurgandy??????????
Brownslave688
You want a toe? I can get you a toe.
They each have their own group. Educating ones self is almost always going to turn out for the positive.
I'm talking about pushing kids into things they have no intrest in. We wouldn't dare say a kid who wants to be a doctor should be required to have 3 years of auto classes. So why do we require a kid who wants to be a mechanic to take 3 years of biology?
DriveInDriveOut
Inordinately Right
Well they shouldn't, but I don't know that kids do take three years of biology. High school for me was physical science, biology, chemistry, then physics. I learned a lot of valuable information. Those classes especially can be greatly beneficial to people who will go on to learn trades, which often have a lot in common with engineering sciences.
A lot of it comes down to learning how to learn. Sounds silly, but being able to learn is itself a skill a lot of people don't have, and a lower education system that teaches to the test doesn't help with that.
Catatonic
Nine Lives
Syphilis?
Catatonic
Nine Lives
Depends on how one defines a 'good job'!
oldngray
nowhere special
with a happy ending?
DriveInDriveOut
Inordinately Right
Brownslave688
You want a toe? I can get you a toe.
But how they learn is most often the difference in good trades students and good school students.
Good trade student learn by hands on training.
rod
Retired 22 years
DriveInDriveOut
Inordinately Right
True.
I was fortunate enough to go to a good school where all of those, except physics which I almost failed, were lab classes. A lot of kids wouldnt ever see a science lab class till college. It's a shame.
AsweetGirl
Is No Longer Affiliated With UPS
BrownArmy
Well-Known Member
I had two years of a 'classical liberal' college education.
I dropped out, because I had no idea what I was doing, and I just wanted to play rock and roll.
Several years later, I went back to college, got a science degree, and was quite happy. I wouldn't trade the education I received for anything.
Critical thinking skills aren't generally innate, and being challenged on your beliefs is a good thing. Learning how to learn is invaluable, and going to a trade school vs. a typical four year college doesn't change that.
I learned enough math in college to get me through...it's not my thing, and I don't enjoy it.
Kids in 'trade schools' these days probably need to learn way more computer science and math than I ever did - it's just the nature of the world.
And now I'm a well-educated truck driver.
Wasting my time posting on BC.
I dropped out, because I had no idea what I was doing, and I just wanted to play rock and roll.
Several years later, I went back to college, got a science degree, and was quite happy. I wouldn't trade the education I received for anything.
Critical thinking skills aren't generally innate, and being challenged on your beliefs is a good thing. Learning how to learn is invaluable, and going to a trade school vs. a typical four year college doesn't change that.
I learned enough math in college to get me through...it's not my thing, and I don't enjoy it.
Kids in 'trade schools' these days probably need to learn way more computer science and math than I ever did - it's just the nature of the world.
And now I'm a well-educated truck driver.
Wasting my time posting on BC.
bottomups
Bad Moon Risen'
.....and some of us are gifted anatomically.
Operational needs
Virescit Vulnere Virtus
bottomups
Bad Moon Risen'
Just hanging around.
Coming down from the high of my annual muskie tournament.
Us muskie anglers walk softly but carry a big stick.
refineryworker05
Well-Known Member
Germany has strong labor unions. America does not. So learning a trade in America may not be as valuable as in Germany. That's partly why they have the system they have. We keep pretending that some snobbery against "blue collar" work is the issue in America, but that's not the primary driver.
Last edited:
refineryworker05
Well-Known Member
In America, we have a whole political party that is anti-labor and anti- making blue collar jobs lucrative.
I remember when the auto industry was renegotiating its contract during the GWBush administration. And Fox News was constantly spewing about how much auto workers made and how they destroyed the auto industry. This kind of thinking dominates conservatives that union wages destroyed the Detroit auto industry. Instead the model for the American auto industry is contract work with no permanency and crap benefits and low wages. That's what Republicans want for those workers. Whenever those workers try to unionize you have elected US Senators and Governors threatening those workers.
That kind of sustained attack against labor is what makes blue collar jobs less valuable in America. So if Mike Rowe isn't addressing those kinds of issues, he is just peeing into the wind.
I remember when the auto industry was renegotiating its contract during the GWBush administration. And Fox News was constantly spewing about how much auto workers made and how they destroyed the auto industry. This kind of thinking dominates conservatives that union wages destroyed the Detroit auto industry. Instead the model for the American auto industry is contract work with no permanency and crap benefits and low wages. That's what Republicans want for those workers. Whenever those workers try to unionize you have elected US Senators and Governors threatening those workers.
That kind of sustained attack against labor is what makes blue collar jobs less valuable in America. So if Mike Rowe isn't addressing those kinds of issues, he is just peeing into the wind.
Similar threads
