Is that really our only three choices? Hitler was a big christian guy though, so it's actually just two choices. And then you have to figure which god is the right one, which leads to the Homer Simpson conundrum:
"Suppose we've chosen the wrong god? Every time we go to church, we're just making him madder and madder."
Sure there is some wisdom in Homer's statement, However, I think the three choices still exist., although I think the choices are not the men themselves, but the attitudes that many have. I highly doubt that Hitler's "chistianity" ever once got in the way of his choices and actions , if anything his christianity was subjected and put in service of his desires. A little honest reflection on what religion is all about might lead one to believe that it is a matter of subjecting and refining your desires and putting them in service of your god.
In terms of what I mentioned about Hitler, what is the Devil if not another word for the term Deified evil ?(You see, I deify, add a D to the word evil and make it devil.) . Cute pun but serious point, many of us, deify evil, we worship it under the guise of worshipping god which is a shortened version of his full name, Good. I am just as guilty of it as others but by trying to be aware of it and trying to slightly change it, I think I am better off than I was before.
Note: literary license was taken to make a point
I wasn't there when he did pray , but I assume that when Hitler prayed, he wasn't asking God what his will was but was asking god for the power and energy to, not fulfill HIS will, but to fulfill his(hitler's will) , like many of us , including me more times than I care to admit.
And Hitler resorted to the black arts in an attempt to obtain supernatural power to fulfil his dreams. Hardly the actions of a christian. Sort of akin to When king Saul obtained the aid of the witch of endor in order to communicate with the spirit of the dead Samuel. ( Hence, the name of Endora for SAMantha's mother in Bewitched) . Hardly the actions of a fine jew.
in closing, I am going to quote (paraphrase) what Abraham Lincoln had to say about religion . " I respect a man's religion to the degree that his dog is better off for him having that religion" . I don't think that is the actual quote but close enough.
So, if a man after having a conversion to a particular religion, ends up kicking his dog harder and more frequently or just as hard and frequently as before he made the conversion, I see no beneficial effects of that religion, or at least of the religion as he (the dog kicker) perceives it.
Since you brought up the simpsons, I would tend to think Lisa's comments and musing about god and religion are more thought provoking but that Marge is probably the much better christian than any of them in thought and action. All imperfect, but hey who isn't .
My thoughts on religion is something akin to this statement " I am not in competition with you or him , but with the man I was yesterday " Sometimes I win that competition and sometimes I don't but yet I still breath so there is still hope.