I'm a rather big fan of Caterpillar myself.
Personal story: When I first started, I got a bargain pair...and ended up needing to see a podiatrist...who said the shoes were NOT the problem. Finally decided to simply try and change shoes, enticed by a sale on Caterpillars, and the problems went away.
The Caterpillars were comfortable enough and with me being a creature of habit and routine, I wore them all the time, not just for work.
Now, as an air driver, I have gotten away from the steel toe boots.
Speaking of sales of caterpillars: If there is a Meijer store in your area, they have pretty good prices, and, in the past, on Thanksgiving Day (not black Friday), they have a buy one, get a second pair of equal or lesser value free sale.
I have worn the "Birmingham" style and have found the brown leather to be both more comfortable and durable than the black leather.