Actually, I would call this over the top discipline that should not occur. But there is more to this story than just this video shows. I am in no way saying that the whole episode is justified, it is not. One thing, does anyone see a chance that this video was set up by the daughter and her refusal to submit to what could have been a mild punishment created the harsher actions of the Dad?
When the vid starts, the light is turned off as Dad leaves the room. It sounds to me that her told her to leave the light off and as soon as he leaves she turns it right back on and waits for him to return. Then she refuses to cooperate knowing this will outrage the Dad. By the conversation she has repeatedly disobeyed the rules and has been in trouble a lot. Again, not saying this whole ordeal is right but some of the responsibility has to fail on the daughter, she (at the time the video was made) is 15 years old, not 5. I know at 15 I knew what made my Dad really mad and did my best not do those things.
This is a prime example of why we shouldn't make judgements based on one side of the story.