I Knock Over Your Block Tower, a Metaphor For Socialism

rickyb

Well-Known Member
We have come from a long history of scarce resources. People are used to gorging themselves during the harvest, in preparation for the coming winter of potential starvation. What is supposed to happen when the harvest is continual and the winter never comes?
yes but im sure cornel west would say this is a more recent phenomenon last few decades of commercialism excess. 1960s had an "excess of democracy" in america, the present doesnt compare to back then, or maybe the new deal wouldve been another era, i dont know.
 

zubenelgenubi

I'm a star
It would be incredible to consider working conditions in the Industrial Revolution (including today, in countries that have been rapidly industrializing) as what occurs when people 'are left to pursue their own goals and interests.'
Some people are willing to risk life and limb to keep their families from starving. Doesn't mean that fact should be exploited, just a reality. Most that flock to unsafe working conditions do so because they don't have much freedom to do anything else.

It is likely that this 'emergent economic system' would not have gotten off the ground without 1. the plundering of the Americas and 2. government-authorized projects of land enclosure which 'freed' people from the ability to grow food to sustain themselves and shunted them into the emerging wage labor market. For a modern analogue to the way England 'encouraged' its peasants to enlist in the workshops, and eventually, the factories, see what's happened in China over the last 50 years. From the outset and throughout its development, there's no way to separate flows of capital from state power.
A lot of that is speculative. It may simply be the case that there is no way to separate flows of capital from state power. The sooner we realize that, the sooner we can head off the worst abuses stemming from that fact.

Wage labor has frequently been compared to slavery. While 'free labor' working for wages was uncommon in ancient Greece and Rome, it was viewed with disdain. In modern times Frederick Douglass spoke of a 'slavery of wages only a little less galling and crushing in its effects than chattel slavery'. And of course, wage slavery was catchphrase of the workers' movement and unions even here in the US -- no doubt used by our Teamster brothers in 1934.
Ok.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Some people are willing to risk life and limb to keep their families from starving. Doesn't mean that fact should be exploited, just a reality. Most that flock to unsafe working conditions do so because they don't have much freedom to do anything else.
why do we have so little freedom?
 

SLW

Well-Known Member
We all knew, or maybe were, that kid in kindergarten whose mission in life it was to destroy anything the other kids spent their free play time building. You finally put that last block on top of your three foot tower, everything perfectly balanced, it's a thing of beauty you and a couple of buddies put your heart into. Then the class ass swings by and kicks it down. He has the audacity to say that it's your fault, and that you aren't a good tower-builder.

That's the process of starting to install a socialist system in a nutshell. People like that are why we can't have nice things.
Marxists? Nah. Marx would've liked the tower. He said that capitalism was the greatest economic system that existed to date, accomplishing more great things than all the previous systems combined in a period of less than 100 years, and a necessary prerequisite for any good socialism might bring about.

Non-Marxist Socialists? Anarchists? Angry anti-capitalist college kids? Yeah, probably.
 

SLW

Well-Known Member
Ricky, in most historical socialist countries, so much as questioning the leadership was a one way ticket to hell.

This one lets you rail against it ad nauseum, and does nothing to silence you.
There was an old saying that was something like, in the Soviet Union, you can criticize your boss but not your politicians, in the US you can criticize your politicians, but not your boss.

Luckily we're Teamsters, so we can do both.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
There was an old saying that was something like, in the Soviet Union, you can criticize your boss but not your politicians, in the US you can criticize your politicians, but not your boss.

Luckily we're Teamsters, so we can do both.
ive worked alot of union jobs and its never been good enough.
 

BadIdeaGuy

Moderator
Staff member
i think thats the problem but its not my expectations. everyones has been artificially lowered.
Ever notice that your stance is always that the entire world is wrong but you?

That no one else has a clue, but you have all the answers?

That's your first sign, Ricky.
 

rickyb

Well-Known Member
Ever notice that your stance is always that the entire world is wrong but you?

That no one else has a clue, but you have all the answers?

That's your first sign, Ricky.
i never said i have all the answers and i quite frequently say i dont know like i just did in response to a relgious question but maybe know where to look for some answers.

you could argue people are almost as confident that capitalism is the right system. my expectations have been lowered too but they are at least higher than htey were.
 
Last edited:
Top